How To Make Easy NYC-style Rye Bagels
Everything you love about rye bread in bagel form! This recipe can be done in less than 3 hours and uses a blend of organic rye and bread flours.
Combine hot water and caraway seeds to steep. Let cool until lukewarm (90-110F).
1
Add bread flour, rye flour, salt, sugar, and instant yeast in the bowl of a stand mixer with a dough hook.
2
With the mixer running on low, slowly add the water and caraway seeds. Mix on low until the dough comes together and no dry bits of flour remain.
3
Increase speed to medium and knead 3-4 mins until dough is smooth and slightly tacky. Transfer to lightly greased container. Cover, let rise 1 hour.
4
When the dough has doubled, punch it down, cover, and let rest 10 more minutes.
5
Divide the dough into eight pieces with a scale. Tuck the ends under and shape into rounds on an *unfloured* surface. Cover and rest 10-15 minutes.
6
Dip your thumb in flour and poke a hole through the bottom of each dough round. Gently rotate and squeeze to stretch and shape each bagel.
7
Boil 1 to 2 minutes per side. Then brush with an egg wash. Bake 20-22 minutes at 425F. Let cool before slicing.
8
What you'll need
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Affiliate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
organic rye flour
caraway seeds
Buy
Stand Mixer With Dough Hook
Buy
Kitchen Scale
Buy
My shop
Check out the products I love
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Affiliate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Kitchen Scale
Buy
In 6 guides
Stand Mixer With Dough Hook
Buy
In 3 guides
wire spider
Buy
In 3 guides
Small Offset Spatula
Buy
In 3 guides
parchment paper
Buy
In 2 guides
bench scraper
Buy
In 2 guides
Whisk
Buy
In 2 guides
ice cream maker
Buy
In 2 guides
bowl scraper
Buy
In 2 guides
blender
Buy
In 2 guides
Pastry Brush
Buy
In 2 guides
2 Quart Sauce Pot
Buy
In 1 guides
Wire Mesh Strainer
Buy
In 1 guides
caraway seeds
Buy
In 1 guides
muffin tins
Buy
In 1 guides
3 TBSP cookie scoop
Buy
In 1 guides
mini food processor
Buy
In 1 guides
organic rye flour
In 1 guides
ice pop molds
Buy
In 1 guides
flaky salt
Buy
In 1 guides
Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt
Buy
In 1 guides
loaf pan
Buy
In 1 guides
Canning Jars
Buy
In 1 guides
Round Cookie Cutters
Buy
In 1 guides
microplane
Buy
In 1 guides
9x13" Cake Pan
Buy
In 1 guides
Cake Board
Buy
In 1 guides
Cake Decorating Turntable
Buy
In 1 guides
large piping bag
Buy
In 1 guides
4" acetate cake collar
Buy
In 1 guides
6” cutter
Buy
In 1 guides
Powdered Pectin
Buy
In 1 guides
Habanero Powder
Buy
In 1 guides
Ravioli Stamp
Buy
In 1 guides
View full shop
Explore more Jumprope
Want to create? It’s fast, easy, free & open to anyone.
Learn more.
More than 50,000 step-by-step guides to learn how to do anything.