Crewmate Among Us Cookies
Start with “Perfectly Tender And Tasty Sugar Cookies.” This recipe helps the cookies hold their shape. The dough does NOT need to be chilled first.
1
Roll cookie dough to 1/4” thickness. Dip the cutters in flour first and then press out cookies. Bake @ 350F for 7 minutes.
2
Use “How To Make Royal Icing For Sugar Cookies” to mix icing. Gradually add water until the frosting gently pours, but isn’t runny.
3
Mix desired Crew Mate colors. Fill piping bags. Use a plastic bench scraper to push all of the icing down. Twist the top and tie the extra in a knot.
4
Cut off a the tip for a very small whole. Start with the borders and let the icing dry a little- about 5 minutes.
5
Next we can fill in the mask with light grey. Start with the edges and then fill in completely. Use a cookie pick to smooth out the icing.
6
Add a small white line to create a “light reflection” on the Crew Mate mask.
7
Now it’s time to fill in the rest of our Crew Mate. Use a cookie pick to smooth out all of the icing.
8
Make a lime colored Crew Mate 💚
9
And an orange Crew Mate 🧡
10
Let dry completely. 12-24 hours before bagging or packaging.
11
What you'll need
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Affiliate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Tipless Piping Bags
Buy
Cookie Pick
Buy
Chefmaster Food Coloring Gel
Buy
3.5 inch
Among Us Cookie Cutters
Buy
My shop
Check out the products I love
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Affiliate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Tipless Piping Bags
Buy
In 4 guides
Enamled Dutch Oven
Buy
In 3 guides
Chefmaster Food Coloring Gel
Buy
In 3 guides
Cuisinart Smart Stick
Buy
In 2 guides
Cookie Pick
Buy
In 2 guides
Lodge Cast Iron Pan
Buy
In 2 guides
Merkens Chocolate
Buy
In 1 guide
Cake Pop Stand
Buy
In 1 guide
Microwave Rice Cooker
Buy
In 1 guide
Mayonaise
In 1 guide
Dried Parsley
In 1 guide
Celery Seed
In 1 guide
Apple Cider Vinegar
In 1 guide
Dill Pickle Relish
In 1 guide
Bacon
In 1 guide
Red Onion
In 1 guide
Russet Potatoes
In 1 guide
Mandolin Slicer
Buy
In 1 guide
Food Saver
Download
In 1 guide
Meat Thermometer
Buy
In 1 guide
Rainbow Cookie Cutter
Buy
In 1 guide
Meat Masher
Buy
In 1 guide
Ice Cream Cone Cookie Cutter
Buy
In 1 guide
Color Pallet
Buy
In 1 guide
Cookie Turntable And Brushes
Buy
In 1 guide
View full shop
Explore more Jumprope
Want to create? It’s fast, easy, free & open to anyone.
Learn more.
More than 50,000 step-by-step guides to learn how to do anything.